Responses to Malcom Gladwell’s social media article

Malcom Gladwell’s New Yorker piece about his skepticism of social media’s role in social change has brought out the heavyweights, and in the past few days there’s been some really great writing about the idea. Anil Dash, in particular, raises the point that the actions of the Maker community are actually political, even though it usually just looks like they’re having fun.

We have had an enormous and concerted act of social disobedience play out over the past half-decade, where millions have decided that the present regime of intellectual property law and corporate control over the way we communicate is no longer tenable. So, every day, with the click of a button, people from all walks of life are ignoring the law and protesting in public, simply by uploading content to YouTube or Facebook or anywhere else.

Eric Harvey responds to Dash’s piece with some skepticism of his own, saying that maybe these things shouldn’t be described as a “revolution,” but rather “something that middle-class people with lots of spare time on their hands and a healthy disregard for corporations do.”

Lots of smart stuff coming out, and I expect to see more. Regardless of the ability of social media to produce social change, it sure is a good way to disseminate writing about itself.

Best Game Ever in Bing Crosby’s cellar – history and the analog hole

Stories like the discovery of Bing Crosby’s copy of the previously lost Game 7 of the 1960 World Series are fun, and not totally uncommon. Earlier this year the National Jazz Museum acquired the Savory Collection of about 1,000 discs of radio broadcasts of jazz greats that had been recorded from radio broadcasts by an enthusiastic audio engineer, and a bootleg of a Woody Guthrie concert that surfaced a few years back is the only known recording of him playing live.

Crosby, the singer and movie, radio and TV star, had more foresight than the television networks and stations, which erased or discarded nearly all of the Major League Baseball games they carried until the 1970s.

Today Major League Baseball is notoriously strict about the rights to their games. It makes you wonder how much of this history we could lose as companies attempt to close the analog hole and average people lose the ability to record their media.

Obama administration’s encryption proposal and the Clipper chip

William Safire’s 1994 response to the Clipper chip works as a smart and poignant response to the Obama administration’s reported proposal to weaken encryption so “secure” communications can be wiretapped. The Safire piece is too good and too short to excerpt.

The story of the “crypto wars” and the Clipper chip in the 80s and 90s is a really interesting one, and worth looking over. Steven Levy’s Crypto is a great book that addresses it, and it’s a fun and informative read. If you’re more into primary sources, articles about the Clipper’s introduction, problematic development, and ultimate defeat are all worth reading, and should be required for anybody thinking about the current proposal.

links for 2010-09-27

  • A call for tweet data older than what is available on the site. It's nice to make the call, and it's great if Twitter listens, but unless you own your own data or have some control over the services you use, you're beholden to a corporation to make decisions in your best interest and often against theirs. The Twitter history issue is a good reminder of why open APIs and the like are not sufficient for free network services.
    (tags: [twitter](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/twitter) [socialmedia](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/socialmedia) [identica](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/identica) [statusnet](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/statusnet))
  • An interesting look at the etymology of "left" and "right" in a bunch of languages. One thing I'm left curious about, though: given the common relationship between "left" and "north," where does English's "southpaw" come from?
    (tags: [language](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/language) [etymology](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/etymology) [left](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/left) [right](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/right) [directions](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/directions) [word](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/word))
  • Clipper 2.0: The US government is preparing to seek new regulation that will undermine encryption technology so that it can be wiretapped. I don't love drug dealers or terrorists, but it's hard to imagine clear-thinking people who see this as a good idea.
    (tags: [encryption](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/encryption) [internet](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/internet) [clipper](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/clipper) [cryptography](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/cryptography) [nytimes](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/nytimes) [article](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/article) [interesting](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/interesting) [government](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/government) [politics](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/politics))
  • WOW does this article ever miss the point. A criticism of the people who advocate giving non-rivalrous goods away in order to generate demand for rivalrous goods, calling them hypocritical for doing exactly what they suggest. (I think that makes them hypercrites!)
    (tags: [article](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/article) [stupid](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/stupid) [freemium](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/freemium) [corydoctorow](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/corydoctorow) [free](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/free))
  • Congratulations to the Diaspora guys on a great New York magazine profile. This piece seems to miss the point less, although it's hard to find a source that isn't posing D* as a Facebook killer.
    (tags: [facebook](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/facebook) [socialmedia](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/socialmedia) [newyork](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/newyork) [diaspora](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/diaspora) [article](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/article))
  • Well, some of this skepticism of social networks is well-placed, and I do think social media fanboys get a little breathless when describing the power of Twitter et al. But of course, Gladwell gets a little muddy when talking about the strengths and weaknesses of these loose-tie networks, and this piece certainly doesn't spell the downfall of the Twitterati, but it's worthwhile reading.
    (tags: [malcolmgladwell](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/malcolmgladwell) [newyorker](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/newyorker) [socialmedia](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/socialmedia) [internet](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/internet) [twitter](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/twitter) [facebook](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/facebook) [civildisobedience](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/civildisobedience))

links for 2010-09-23

  • Stuxnet is the craziest malware since Conficker, and if you believe the hype, it's way crazier. Four hitherto unseen Windows zero-days and it targets PLCs! Some researchers are suggesting it was built by a nation-state level entity to target Iran's nuclear power plants, but Schneier in unconvinced.
    (tags: [security](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/security) [bbc](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/bbc) [iran](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/iran) [stuxnet](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/stuxnet) [virus](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/virus) [article](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/article) [crazy](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/crazy) [microsoft](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/microsoft) [windows](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/windows))
  • A discussion from Cory Doctorow about how a lack of statistical literacy and password fundamentals leads to inconvenient and insecure practices. (Also: maybe I'm dense, but this didn't seem like satire. Isn't it weird to call your piece "A modest proposal" and then not be over-the-top satirical?)
    (tags: [corydoctorow](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/corydoctorow) [guardian](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/guardian) [security](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/security) [banking](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/banking) [passwords](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/passwords) [statistics](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/statistics))
  • A somewhat conspicuous but still rather small wearable camcorder/bluetooth headset that can buffer up to five hours of running footage and store four. Next step towards Snowcrash "Gargoyles."
    (tags: [camera](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/camera) [technology](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/technology) [wearable](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/wearable) [video](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/video) [gadget](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/gadget) [privacy](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/privacy))
  • This scary technology takes advantage of the eight or so different places cookies might be stored, and leaves a copy in each spot. If any, but not all, of the cookies get erased, the remaining ones will replace the deleted ones.
    (tags: [privacy](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/privacy) [programming](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/programming) [web](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/web) [cookies](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/cookies) [html](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/html) [javascript](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/javascript) [security](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/security))
  • A profile of Dr. Luke, one of the masterminds behind a surprising number of smash hits in the past few years: "Tik Tok," "California Gurls," "I Kissed A Girl," "Right Round," etc etc. The description of his "curatorial" role is particularly interesting.
    (tags: [article](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/article) [newyork](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/newyork) [magazine](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/magazine) [music](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/music) [pop](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/pop) [drluke](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/drluke) [songwriting](http://delicious.com/parkerhiggins/songwriting))